Keystone Loyalty Rewards vs Otter Loyalty & Rewards

Two Shopify apps, side by side: detected stores, momentum, reviews, plans, listed features and who runs each. Store counts as of Nov 19, 2026 for Keystone Loyalty Rewards, Sep 26, 2026 for Otter Loyalty & Rewards.

The short answer

  • On the Shopify App Store: Keystone Loyalty Rewards 5.0 from 7 reviews and Otter Loyalty & Rewards 4.6 from 22 reviews.
  • Only Keystone Loyalty Rewards lists a free plan. Paid plans start at $14.99/month for Keystone Loyalty Rewards and $15/month for Otter Loyalty & Rewards.
  • Keystone Loyalty Rewards lists 22 features Otter Loyalty & Rewards’s listing doesn’t mention, including APIs and webhooks, Automations, Bulk editing.

Head to head

Detected stores

Keystone Loyalty Rewards: 61
Otter Loyalty & Rewards: —

App Store reviews

Keystone Loyalty Rewards: 7
Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 22

New reviews, 28 days

Keystone Loyalty Rewards: 1
Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 1

Stores added, 28 days

Keystone Loyalty Rewards: 4
Otter Loyalty & Rewards: —
Open this comparison in ShoplistFree account. Every feature, store and change, side by side.
Pitch
—

Affordable Rewards, Referrals & Points Loyalty with VIP Tiers

Categories
  • Loyalty and rewards
  • Discounts
  • Discounts
  • Loyalty and rewards
Languages
  • English
  • English
Launched
Dec 5, 2025
Jul 12, 2021
Built for Shopify
Built for Shopify
Not badged
Reviews per month
1 last full month
1 last full month
Detected stores
61active installs
  • All Diva Things
  • OshunsLight's Boutique
  • Papier Hq
  • Kinetics(キネティクス)|OFFICIAL ONLINE STORE
  • SookSkincare
+56 more
0active installs
Most common store size
11-50 products20%
—
Top countries
  • Netherlands13%
  • United States13%
  • Australia8%
—

Momentum

New reviews each month

Review pace is the clearest public read on how fast an app is winning new merchants.

01020SepJunSepNovJanMayDecMarJulKeystone Loyalty Rewards: 1 reviews in December 2025Keystone Loyalty Rewards: 2 reviews in February 2026Keystone Loyalty Rewards: 1 reviews in March 2026Keystone Loyalty Rewards: 1 reviews in May 2026Keystone Loyalty Rewards: 1 reviews in July 2026Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 2 reviews in September 2023Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 1 reviews in November 2023Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 5 reviews in June 2024Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 2 reviews in July 2024Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 4 reviews in September 2024Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 9 reviews in October 2024Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 12 reviews in November 2024Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 4 reviews in December 2024Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 4 reviews in January 2025Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 2 reviews in April 2025Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 2 reviews in May 2025Otter Loyalty & Rewards: 1 reviews in June 2025
Keystone Loyalty RewardsOtter Loyalty & RewardsCompleted months only
Free options
Free planFree trial
Free planFree trial
Monthly range
From $0 to $79/month
$15/month
Plans
FreeFree
  • · Data import/export
  • · Discount rewards - basic
  • · Dynamic discount codes - basic
  • · Embed loyalty program on product pages
  • · Loyalty points - basic
  • · Storefront widget
Starter$14.99/month
14-day free trialExclusive BFCM Offer for new users! Only $7.49/month for your first 3 months, then $14.99/month.
  • · Custom rewards & emails
  • · Everything included in Free Plan
  • · Gift card rewards
  • · Nudges
  • · POS rewards for in-store customers
  • · Points expiry & notifications
Standard$39/month
14-day free trialExclusive BFCM Offer for new users! Only $19.50/month for your first 3 months, then $39/month.
  • · Discount rewards - advanced
  • · Done-for-you setup by our team
  • · Dynamic discount codes - advanced
  • · Everything included in Starter Plan
  • · Loyalty points - advanced
  • · Thank you page
Growth$79/month
14-day free trialExclusive BFCM Offer for new users! Only $39.50/month for your first 3 months, then $79/month.
  • · $20 per additional 100 orders
  • · 2000 monthly orders included
  • · All advanced features
  • · Everything included in Standard Plan
  • · Integrations (e.g. Klaviyo, Judge.me)
  • · Multi-language & currency storefront
Starter PlanFree to install
100 orders/month included. $10 for every additional 100 orders
  • · All features are unlocked
  • · Automated emails
  • · Bonus events
  • · Custom loyalty page
  • · Membership
  • · Points
Scaler Plan$15/month
300 orders/month included. $5 for every additional 100 orders
  • · All features are unlocked
  • · Integrations
  • · Live chat
  • · Nudges & reminders
  • · Points expiration
  • · Points on product page
Coverage
33 of 40 features83%
18 of 40 features45%
Unique strengths
  • APIs and webhooks
  • Automations
  • Bulk editing
  • Checkout discounts
  • +18 more
  • Custom code
  • Free products
  • Membership perks
  • Memberships
  • +3 more
Discounts
91%20/22
14%3/22
Discount types
100%9/9
11%1/9
Managing discounts
85%11/13
15%2/13
Loyalty and rewards
72%13/18
83%15/18
Program types
83%5/6
67%4/6
Rewards you can offer
67%8/12
92%11/12
22117onlybothonly
Keystone Loyalty RewardsOtter Loyalty & Rewards40 features listed across both App Store listings

Coverage counts what each App Store listing names. Every feature, checked off app by app, is in Shoplist.

See every feature
Works with also listed by another
—
  • Shopify POS
  • Checkout
  • Klaviyo
  • Judge.Me
  • Seal Subscriptions
  • Smile
  • LoyaltyLion
  • Yotpo
How it sells itself

Turn one-time buyers into returning customers with a loyalty program that matches your brand. Set it up in minutes by telling your AI assistant what you want. Award points for purchases, signups & referrals, with conditional rules that control how customers earn. Run promotions like 2x points weekends, VIP tier rewards & custom earning rules. Redeem for gift cards, discounts & free gifts.

Otter Loyalty is a complete loyalty solution with points, rewards, referrals, VIP tiers, membership, and more. It’s built for merchants of all sizes to help drive repeat purchases, acquire new customers, and increase retention. Fully customizable to match your brand. Fully configurable to match your needs. Friendly support for everyone. (Formerly Super Rewards)

Key points
  • Reward customers with points for purchases, signups, birthdays, and more
  • Offer discounts, free shipping, or product deals as exciting customer rewards
  • Create customer tiers with exclusive perks to motivate long-term loyalty
  • Bring in new shoppers with shareable referral rewards to incentivize growth
  • Gift cards can be sent, scheduled, and reminders can be set for customers.
  • Customize the rewards launcher, panel, and emails to align with your brand.
  • Encourage repeat purchases by allowing guest shoppers to earn and redeem points.
  • Nudges to remind customers of their points & referral link, boosting engagement.
Screenshots
Flexible segmentation for stronger loyalty strategies
Grow your customer base using referralsKeystone fully supports Shopify POS in-store rewardsKeystone gives customers rewards access right on their phones
Your brand, your loyalty and rewards program. Fully customizable
Build a customized rewards and referral program. signup birthdayIncrease repeat purchases with loyalty program.Customize your widget, emails, and more!

All the numbers

Every figure, side by side

A green dot marks the app ahead on a measured figure. Estimates, gaps and apps that leave no storefront trace never take the lead.

Showing only the rows where the apps differ.

Adoption

MeasureKeystone Loyalty RewardsOtter Loyalty & Rewards
Detected stores61as of Nov 19, 2026Not published
Net store change, 28 days+4estimated0estimated
Stores added, 28 days4new and returningNot enough data
Big-brand shareNot enough dataNot enough data
Top store categoriesHome & Garden, Apparel & Accessories, Health & BeautyNot published
Top store countriesNetherlands, United States, AustraliaNot published

Reviews

MeasureKeystone Loyalty RewardsOtter Loyalty & Rewards
App Store rating5.0 ★(ahead)4.6 ★
App Store reviews722(ahead)
New reviews, 28 days11
Reviewers a year or more inNot enough dataNot enough data

Pricing

MeasureKeystone Loyalty RewardsOtter Loyalty & Rewards
Free planYesNot listed
Lowest paid monthly plan$14.99/month(ahead)$15/month
Longest free trial14 daysNot listed
Plans listed42

Listing

MeasureKeystone Loyalty RewardsOtter Loyalty & Rewards
Shopify category rank#70(ahead)in Loyalty and rewards#157in Loyalty and rewards
Shopify App Charts#4 on Rookies in Loyalty and rewardsNot on this week’s charts
Built for ShopifyYesNo
LaunchedDec 5, 2025Jul 12, 2021
Languages1English1English
DeveloperKeystoneOkapya Software Solutions Inc.

FAQ

Keystone Loyalty Rewards and Otter Loyalty & Rewards: common questions

Is Keystone Loyalty Rewards or Otter Loyalty & Rewards cheaper?
Only Keystone Loyalty Rewards lists a free plan. Paid plans start at $14.99/month for Keystone Loyalty Rewards and $15/month for Otter Loyalty & Rewards. Shoplist compares base prices only between monthly plans in the same currency; usage charges and annual plans vary, so check each plan’s limits.
Which has better reviews, Keystone Loyalty Rewards or Otter Loyalty & Rewards?
On the Shopify App Store: Keystone Loyalty Rewards 5.0 from 7 reviews and Otter Loyalty & Rewards 4.6 from 22 reviews.
What features does each app list that the other doesn’t?
Keystone Loyalty Rewards lists 22 the others don’t mention, such as APIs and webhooks, Automations, Bulk editing, Checkout discounts. Otter Loyalty & Rewards lists 7 the others don’t mention, such as Custom code, Free products, Membership perks, Memberships. A feature missing from a listing may still be supported; this compares what each App Store listing says.
Where does this comparison’s data come from?
Shoplist crawls Shopify storefronts to detect which apps each store runs, and reads each app’s Shopify App Store listing for reviews, pricing, features and integrations. Store counts are as of Nov 19, 2026 for Keystone Loyalty Rewards, Sep 26, 2026 for Otter Loyalty & Rewards; estimated figures are labeled.

How Shoplist compares apps

Store counts come from Shoplist’s crawl of Shopify storefronts, which detects the apps each store runs; they are as of Nov 19, 2026 for Keystone Loyalty Rewards, Sep 26, 2026 for Otter Loyalty & Rewards. Reviews, ratings, plans, features and integrations come from each app’s Shopify App Store listing. 28-day figures are labeled when estimated, and a figure that is missing or estimated never decides who leads. Read the methodology.