--- title: "Magical Make an Offer vs Pay What You Want: Shopify app comparison" description: "Compare Magical Make an Offer and Pay What You Want on detected Shopify stores, App Store reviews, pricing, listed features and integrations." canonical_url: "https://shoplist.co/shopify-apps/compare/magical-make-an-offer-vs-pay-what-you-want-pwyw" markdown_url: "https://shoplist.co/shopify-apps/compare/magical-make-an-offer-vs-pay-what-you-want-pwyw.md" data_as_of: "Nov 8, 2026" --- # Magical Make an Offer vs Pay What You Want Shopify app comparison from Shoplist. Store counts as of Nov 8, 2026. ## At a glance - Magical Make an Offer is detected on 2.9× as many Shopify stores as Pay What You Want: 511 vs 176 as of Nov 8, 2026. - On the Shopify App Store: Magical Make an Offer 4.7 from 170 reviews and Pay What You Want 4.3 from 56 reviews. - Only Pay What You Want lists a free plan. Paid plans start at $9/month for Magical Make an Offer and $4.99/month for Pay What You Want. - Magical Make an Offer lists 22 features Pay What You Want’s listing doesn’t mention, including Admin alerts, Analytics, Auto-approve. ## Adoption | Measure | Magical Make an Offer | Pay What You Want | Ahead | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Detected stores | 511 — as of Nov 8, 2026 | 176 — as of Nov 8, 2026 | Magical Make an Offer | | Net store change, 28 days | −4 — estimated | \+3 — estimated | | | Stores added, 28 days | 15 — new and returning | 6 — new and returning | Magical Make an Offer | | Big-brand share | 10% — of stores of known size | Not enough data | | | Top store categories | Apparel & Accessories, Arts & Entertainment, Home & Garden | Media, Apparel & Accessories, Services | | | Top store countries | United States, United Kingdom, Canada | United States, Canada, Australia | | ## Reviews | Measure | Magical Make an Offer | Pay What You Want | Ahead | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | App Store rating | 4.7 ★ | 4.3 ★ | Magical Make an Offer | | App Store reviews | 170 | 56 | Magical Make an Offer | | New reviews, 28 days | 2 | 2 | | | Reviewers a year or more in | Not enough data | Not enough data | | ## Pricing | Measure | Magical Make an Offer | Pay What You Want | Ahead | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Free plan | Not listed | Yes | | | Lowest paid monthly plan | $9/month | $4.99/month | Pay What You Want | | Longest free trial | 14 days | 7 days | | | Plans listed | 3 | 3 | | ## Listing | Measure | Magical Make an Offer | Pay What You Want | Ahead | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Shopify category rank | \#18 — in Pricing quotes | \#12 — in Pricing quotes | Pay What You Want | | Shopify App Charts | \#7 in Pricing quotes | \#19 in Pricing quotes | | | Built for Shopify | Yes | Yes | | | Launched | Nov 6, 2015 | Sep 1, 2020 | | | Languages | 1 — English | 1 — English | | | Developer | Magical Apps | Extendons | | ## Listed features - 29 distinct features are listed across these App Store listings; 7 are listed by both. - Magical Make an Offer lists 29 of them (100%). Listed only by Magical Make an Offer: Admin alerts, Analytics, Auto-approve, Auto-decline, Auto-email responses, Auto-repricing, Bidding, Bulk editing, Counter offers, Custom display, Dashboards, Email notifications, Email templates, Percentage discounts, Pop-ups, Price negotiation, Quote form, Quote updates, Reports, Request a quote, Show and hide, Tags. - Pay What You Want lists 7 of them (24%). ### Coverage by App Store category | Category | Magical Make an Offer | Pay What You Want | | --- | --- | --- | | Pricing optimization | 11/11 | 3/11 | | Pricing optimization › Monitoring | 3/3 | 0/3 | | Pricing optimization › Pricing management | 8/8 | 3/8 | | Pricing quotes | 18/18 | 4/18 | | Pricing quotes › Customization | 4/4 | 1/4 | | Pricing quotes › Notifications | 5/5 | 0/5 | | Pricing quotes › Pricing rules | 9/9 | 3/9 | A feature missing from a listing may still be supported; this compares what each App Store listing says. ## Integrations - No platform appears in every listing. - Only Magical Make an Offer lists: Google Analytics. - Only Pay What You Want lists: Digital Download Products. ## Pricing plans ### Magical Make an Offer | Plan | Price | Free trial | Additional charges | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | Starter | Free to install | Not listed | 1% on paid orders only. No sales, no fee. | | Growth | $9/month | 14-day free trial | Only 0.33% on paid orders. | | Power | $199/month | 14-day free trial | Flat rate pricing. No per-order fees. | ### Pay What You Want | Plan | Price | Free trial | Additional charges | | --- | --- | --- | --- | | 30-Days Free Trial | Free | Not listed | None listed | | Core | $4.99/month | 7-day free trial | None listed | | Spark | $8.99/month | 7-day free trial | None listed | ## Frequently asked questions ### Which is more popular, Magical Make an Offer or Pay What You Want? Magical Make an Offer is detected on 2.9× as many Shopify stores as Pay What You Want: 511 vs 176 as of Nov 8, 2026. ### Is Magical Make an Offer or Pay What You Want cheaper? Only Pay What You Want lists a free plan. Paid plans start at $9/month for Magical Make an Offer and $4.99/month for Pay What You Want. Shoplist compares base prices only between monthly plans in the same currency; usage charges and annual plans vary, so check each plan’s limits. ### Which has better reviews, Magical Make an Offer or Pay What You Want? On the Shopify App Store: Magical Make an Offer 4.7 from 170 reviews and Pay What You Want 4.3 from 56 reviews. ### What features does each app list that the other doesn’t? Magical Make an Offer lists 22 the others don’t mention, such as Admin alerts, Analytics, Auto-approve, Auto-decline. A feature missing from a listing may still be supported; this compares what each App Store listing says. ### Where does this comparison’s data come from? Shoplist crawls Shopify storefronts to detect which apps each store runs, and reads each app’s Shopify App Store listing for reviews, pricing, features and integrations. Store counts are as of Nov 8, 2026; estimated figures are labeled. ## Links - [Magical Make an Offer vs Pay What You Want on Shoplist](https://shoplist.co/shopify-apps/compare/magical-make-an-offer-vs-pay-what-you-want-pwyw) - [Magical Make an Offer on Shoplist](https://shoplist.co/shopify-apps/magical-make-an-offer) ([Markdown](https://shoplist.co/shopify-apps/magical-make-an-offer.md)) - [Pay What You Want on Shoplist](https://shoplist.co/shopify-apps/pay-what-you-want-pwyw) ([Markdown](https://shoplist.co/shopify-apps/pay-what-you-want-pwyw.md)) ## Methodology Shoplist crawls Shopify storefronts to detect which apps each store runs, and reads each app’s Shopify App Store listing for reviews, pricing, features and integrations. Store counts for Magical Make an Offer and Pay What You Want are as of Nov 8, 2026. “Not detectable from storefronts” means an app leaves no storefront trace, so Shoplist can’t count its stores. A row names who is ahead only when every app has a measured, unestimated figure. See [data methodology](https://shoplist.co/data-methodology.md).